Peter Weber Is Going to Be a Dad?! Fans Just Found a Baby Registry, and the Internet Is Losing It Because There’s ANOTHER Shocking Twist

Peter Weber may have just accidentally revealed the biggest secret of his life, and Bachelor Nation sleuths think there’s an even bigger twist hiding in the details.

The former Bachelor star recently hard-launched his relationship with Jadeyn Carr, sharing a series of photos that immediately had fans talking.

But it wasn’t just the relationship that caught Bachelor Nation’s attention.

Fans thought they spotted what appeared to be a baby bump in one of the photos.

And then Reddit detectives went digging.

What they allegedly found has turned a simple photo dump into a full-blown pregnancy mystery.

Bachelor Nation thinks Peter Weber is going to be a dad

A Reddit user in the r/BachelorNation community posted about Peter’s latest Instagram photos, writing that his girlfriend appeared to be pregnant.

“I just don’t see how that second photo could be interpreted as anything other than pregnancy,” the original poster wrote. 

At first, some commenters weren’t convinced.

People pointed out that the photo could simply be an unflattering angle, clothing or normal body positioning. Others questioned whether it was fair to speculate about someone’s pregnancy based on a photograph.

Then came the discovery that sent the entire conversation into overdrive.

THAT’S NOT ALL…

A Reddit user reportedly uncovered a Babylist registry associated with Jadeyn Carr and Peter Weber.

Screenshots shared in the Reddit thread showed a registry titled “Jadeyn’s Baby Registry,” with Jadeyn Carr & Peter Weber listed together.

The screenshot also appeared to show a February 5, 2027 date and the initials “J + P.”

And almost immediately after Reddit users began sharing the discovery, commenters said the registry had been made private or password protected.

One user posted the registry link and bluntly wrote, “For people getting mad, here’s their baby registry. She’s pregnant.” Another commenter said they had managed to screenshot it before the privacy settings changed. 

“Boots on the ground journalism. Wow. Bravo,” another Reddit user joked. 

Suddenly, the baby-bump speculation looked a lot more significant.

BUT THAT’S NOT ALL… THERE’S A TWIN CLUE 👀

Just when fans thought they had figured out the mystery, Reddit users noticed something else on the registry.

A double stroller.

One commenter specifically asked whether the person who had screenshotted the registry had captured the stroller, writing:

“Did you screenshot the one with double stroller?!??” 

Another Reddit user then claimed:

“They are having twins.”

Why?

Because, according to commenters who saw the registry before it was locked down, the registry included twin-related items, including a double stroller. 

And THAT has Bachelor Nation wondering whether Peter Weber could be preparing to become a father to not one, but TWO babies.

Of course, a double stroller does not definitively prove twins. Several Reddit users pointed out that parents sometimes buy double strollers when they plan to have another child in the future, or for other practical reasons. One commenter said they had purchased one with their first child despite not having twins. 

Still, given the alleged February due date, the apparent pregnancy and the registry being associated with both Peter and Jadeyn, fans are understandably putting the clues together.

And Bachelor Nation is going WILD

The Reddit comments quickly turned into a mixture of shock, jokes and detective work.

“Pilot Pete is going to be a dad?! Sweet Nums will be ALL over herself,” one commenter wrote, referring to Peter’s famously enthusiastic mom, Barbara Weber. 

Another simply reacted:

“That’s insane.” 

One user admitted they initially thought everyone was simply overanalyzing the photograph—until the registry appeared.

“I was ready to be like ‘omg people let a woman have a burrito!’ But then someone found the baby registry and moments later it became password protected,” the commenter wrote, adding that it suddenly seemed much more convincing. 

Another Reddit user questioned how someone had even discovered the registry in the first place, while others criticized the decision to post what may have been a private registry online.

“Finding her registry and posting it on reddit is so weird and creepy,” one commenter wrote. 

Another said they were worried the couple may have been planning to make the announcement themselves and that the discovery could have spoiled their surprise. 

Fans are even debating whether Peter accidentally teased the pregnancy

The Instagram photos themselves have become part of the investigation.

The original Reddit post argued that Carr’s appearance in one particular photo looked unmistakably like a pregnancy bump. Other commenters disagreed, pointing out that people can look different depending on their pose, clothes and angle. 

Then one Redditor took the speculation even further, suggesting that something Carr was holding might actually have been a pregnancy test that had been edited or obscured.

That theory remains unconfirmed, but it only added fuel to the discussion. 

And what about the “twins” theory?

This is where things get especially interesting.

One Reddit commenter noticed that Peter’s mother had left two heart emojis on his post and jokingly wondered whether that could be a hint that the couple is expecting twins.

Another user immediately responded that it was probably a stretch. 

So, no—the two hearts aren’t exactly evidence.

The double stroller is the much more interesting clue.

If the registry screenshots circulating on Reddit are legitimate and the couple really did have a double stroller among their requested items, then twins are certainly one possible explanation.

But until Peter and Jadeyn say otherwise, Bachelor Nation is connecting dots—not confirming a twin pregnancy.

So, is Peter Weber really going to be a dad?

As of now, Peter Weber and Jadeyn Carr have not publicly confirmed a pregnancy or twins.

What has been circulating online is a combination of Peter’s new relationship announcement, fans’ interpretation of one of the photos, and screenshots of an alleged Babylist registry bearing their names and a February 5, 2027 date. Reddit users also claim the registry contained a double stroller and was subsequently made private. 

That is certainly enough to make Bachelor Nation suspicious.

And if the registry is genuine?

Pilot Pete could soon be trading Bachelor drama for diaper duty.

And possibly…

DOUBLE diaper duty. 👀👶👶

For now, though, the biggest question remains:

Did Peter Weber accidentally hard-launch his girlfriend… AND his future babies at the same time?

Bachelor Nation is waiting. ✈️👶👶